AMALIA’S TALE/SYPHILIS/UGLINESS?


P1000513As I do not have a picture of a person suffering from syphilis  I just add these ones from sick grapes and  apples and hope they will do the trick!

You can also listen to the summary of the book:AMALIA’STALE  and check the vocabulary on this list (English/Deutsch/italiano)AMALIAVOCABULARY

I’ve also prepared an exercise about the disease with answers which you can drag from the right hand side to the correct question on the left. Correct it online!http://www.langedi49.ch/SYPHILIS.htm

As Klausbernd analysed on his blog the question of how ugliness came into culture and what it  stood for, according to the various periods of literature, the book „AMALIA’S TALE” by David I. Kertzer, which I have read some time ago, came into my mind.

SUMMARY OF THE BOOK

The main character in the book is Amalia Bagnacavalli from Vergato, a village in the hills near Bologna, Italy. Her tragedy happens towards the end of the 19th century. Amalia is an illiterate peasant woman who  becomes  a wet- nurse of an abandoned infant from the foundling home in Bologna. Taking in those children is an old tradition in the mountain communities gives them a little bit of money.In that period it was not allowed to women out-of-wedlock to raise children. Unfortunately, however,  Amalia catches syphilis from the baby Paola who dies soon. Not only does this infant die but she loses also her own daughter and her husband also gets it and they suffer from it all for years and years. Within short many other wet nurses or family members are mottled and end in the same way.

Sypphilis

Sypphilis

Where is ugliness or where is beauty?

Despite this tragedy, Amalia fights for about ten years for her rights against the foundling home, the medical, aristocratic and political establishment  which is afraid of losing its reputation.( The foundling home does not accept the early signs such as blindness ad spinal deformity.) with the help of a young, ambitious and greedy  lawyer, Barbieri, who in the end wins the case and becomes rich,whereas Amalia remains poor and destroyed by all her losses.

 On page 141 in the book I read also about an emblematic case in Genoa in which a wet-nurse is informed by  her rural town doctor that she has syphilitic sore on her breast and to give the baby back, but the foundling  home doctor insists that the baby is healthy and sends it to another wet-nurse, Domenica, who then also contacts the illness and dies leaving behind a husband and ten children!

  1. QUESTION:

     Who or what is ugly according to you ? A newborn baby with syphilis or a lawyer, who manages the money, due to the  victim, in a way that he himself becomes wealthy whereas the victim remains poor?

  2.QUESTION:

     With whom is ugliness if, like in the case of Amalia, Domenica and many others, doctors and authorities try to hide the truth and without much hesitation sacrifice other people’s lives?

 On page 143 the author writes that Foundling homes had for centuries been places where they experimented on artificial feeding on newborns, especially on those babies suspected to  have syphilis. It seems that there were strong oppositions against this practice, not only because consigning the newborn to animal milk was widely regarded as a death sentence, but also because of popular beliefs  that those  babies who did survive acquired the traits of the animal whose milk had nourished them.

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s